Thumb Score: +14

Aomtelove via Amazon.com has 17” Letsmeet Large Squeaky Alligator Dog Toys for $5.99.
Shipping is free with Prime or on $35+ orders.

Style: Alligator [amazon.com] $5.99
Style: Dog [amazon.com] $4.99 w/ Prime
Style: Octopus [amazon.com] $4.99 w/ Prime
Style: Big-faced frog [amazon.com]$4.99 w/ Prime
Style: Elephant [amazon.com] $4.99 w/ Prime