Thumb Score: +28

Amazon [amazon.com] has 16-Oz Blue Buffalo Health Bars Crunchy Dog Biscuits (Pumpkin & Cinnamon) for $4.98 – $1.25 – 35% at checkout – 5% when you check out via Subscribe & Save = $1.74.
Shipping is free with Prime or on $35+ orders.

Savings
Coupon price $3.73 (check and activate [amazon.com])