Thumb Score: +19

Amazon [amazon.com] has 2-Pack Revlon ColorStay Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil w/ Built-In Sharpener (Black) on sale for $11.38 – $1.99 when you ‘clip’ the coupon, then switch to Subscribe & Save for 40% off when you ‘clip’ the coupon on product page [amazon.com] – 5% off when you checkout via Subscribe & Save = $4.27. Shipping is free w/ Prime or on orders $35+.